2.06.2013

This one won't win me any friends.

Ironic, isn't it? The thing that would bring me out of blog silence would be the sport I dislike most.

Yes, football. The Super Bowl. The Big Game.

I've been struggling with my thoughts since Sunday night, when I came downstairs after putting my son to bed and my husband hit rewind so I could catch the half-time show. He knows it's the only part I like. Except this year it wasn't; this year the only part of the night I liked was watching survivors from Sandy Hook Elementary School sing "America the Beautiful."

As talented as Beyonce is, I'll never like the fact that she utilizes her body as a marketing tool and allows people across the world to see her as a sex object. I'll never enjoy watching her lick her finger and rub it down her chest. I'll never smile as she writhes on the floor. I just won't.

I'll wager that millions of Americans were excited by it, and Beyonce is no dummy. She knows this. She's known this for a long time. Years ago I watched her teach Oprah how to shake her booty on Oprah's afternoon talk show.

Please don't think I am pointing my finger merely at her. She is but one of thousands of women who have allowed themselves to be exploited by some form of media, and in many ways they are all victims. But you know what? Victim or perpetrator, it's wrong.

I saw the now infamous Go Daddy commercial before the Super Bowl even aired, and I admit I struggled with how to feel about it. Why did it disgust me? Why are we so revolted by a chubby geek kissing a beautiful woman? Are we (am I?) really as shallow as the ad producers think we are? But the more I think about it, the more I realize his geekiness and her hotness aren't the point at all. As Lisa-Jo Baker said more eloquently than I can, "There was not even the decency of pretense. No facade of intimacy, romance or relationship. There was just sex dressed up as a kiss that was intended to revolt. And generate sales." In other words, the Go Daddy commercial was just another version of the half-time show -- sex dressed up for sales.

Lest you think Lisa-Jo is a football hater like me, who went into the night with a negative attitude, let me share her words: "There is an awesomeness to the spectacular of the Super Bowl. A modern man’s arena, a Herculean struggle between athletes that have hurt and trained and arrived to take home a piece of history. [...]  I get the symbolism and the patriotism and the flat out, crazy fun of the moment."

Unlike me, Lisa-Jo is not anti-football. Her hot emotion stemmed from the embarrassment and shock of her 5-year-old and 7-year-old boys after watching all those commercials. (They were not at home, or else Lisa-Jo says she would have changed the channel.) The one that disturbed them most was the young man trying to take his favorite t-shirt off a sleeping young woman and sneak out of the house. How does a mom explain that scenario to two little boys? One day I'll have to know the answer to that question, because even if we throw away our television, I can't lock Henry in our house forever.

Until that day, I'm encouraged by this timely article, "Confessions of a 'Prude,'" from Relevantmagazine.com. See, making remarks like those I've made today isn't popular. Not even in church. Maybe especially not in church. Nobody wants to be the self-righteous goody-goody who has no fun. But that's not at all what I want to endorse. What I want to say is that it's ok to be disturbed by too much skin, too much sex for sale. It is possible to be both modest and culturally relevant.

My favorite part of the article is when Andrew Byers says, "I have no interest in promoting the trends of legalism, moralism and cultural irrelevance that the Church just can't seem to shake. My point, rather, is that innocence is precious and that preserving it is not a vice.If you have 5 minutes, read his entire article for yourself. I'll be back soon with more of my thoughts on modesty.

6 comments:

  1. I do have a question, given your comment on my post and this article, did the halftime show bother you most because it was a nationally-televised event? I ask, not in judgement (obviously) but out of curiosity. A few days ago you shared how much you enjoyed "Homeland," so much that you couldn't wait for season three to come out (I totally get it, I love the show, too), but we both know that the first half of season one was images of "soft-core" pornography interspersed with graphic torture scenes. I am assuming that, like me, you turned away at those parts but kept watching because the story line was so compelling.

    So when you commented that you were disgusted on my post, I was a little surprised. I reevaluated my own thoughts about the halftime show in light of your comment, because we can only benefit from some "sharpening" from a trusted friend. I was not offended in any way by you sharing your thoughts, not at all! But it did make me wonder about some of the shows that we both enjoy that show way more skin than Beyonce did that night.

    So was it because of the more universal nature of the halftime show? That I totally get. We too were at a party, but the kids were playing with friends most of the night and barely gave the TV a glance. Commercials during sporting events almost always tick me off, for the reasons Lisa-Jo (and you) so wonderfully stated. Don't even get me started on the previews for horror movies that are shown during afternoon college basketball games...

    I wasn't going to bring any of this up, but then you brought it up again, so I did, too. (Grin) I hope this doesn't read as criticism, it certainly isn't intended that way. I highly value your thoughts on most every subject, so I would just like you to expound a little more on halftime vs. homeland.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And if I can continue with a comment that is longer than your post (ha ha), I just want to stress the fact that I am not even hinting at any hypocrisy on your part. (I know you know that, but I want your friends who don't know me as well to know that.) It's just that I struggle with these questions so often... I am a total TV snob, and I only watch shows that I consider to be well-written, but unfortunately so many of those shows maintain their edginess by bringing in nudity and violence (The Wire, Mad Men, Smash are some of my favorites). Maybe that's why I am obsessed with Downton Abbey! The writing is spectacular, and there has been no gratuitous anything, other than elitist snobbery.

      I stopped watching Gray's years ago, and Mad Men two seasons ago because I knew I was risking my anointing by watching. But then Homeland comes along and I am lapping it up like a little kitten at a bowl of milk, and then scratching the bowl for more when it's gone.

      So what's the answer? PBS only? No television, just books (not a *terrible* idea)? Where do we as followers of Christ draw a line?

      Anyway, I just wanted to elaborate... even more.

      Delete
  2. Yes, you hit the nail on the head! I'm bothered by the fact that it's network television (and before many children's bedtimes). Keith and I do love Homeland, and if I expected a show on Showtime not to be graphic, I'd be crazy, right? :) I go into each episode knowing there will be moments when I need to shut my eyes and use my ears to determine when to open them again. I am ashamed to admit that in my past I didn't bother to even close my eyes or look away during certain shows and movies, and I now have images in my brain that I truly despise and can't erase. I think my own struggle with this issue is what makes me get so fired up. Like you, I've been convicted to stop watching a lot of what's on TV, yet my favorites are Breaking Bad and Homeland. Umm, yeah, that's maybe a problem.

    That said, it's my own sin and own fault if I knowingly choose to watch a Showtime drama and my eyes see something they shouldn't. It's another thing, imho, to be subjected to it during a commercial or nationally-televised sporting event. (Oh, and I hate some of the cheerleader uniforms and dances too.) And even if we turn off our TVs, period, we are still forced to see these images on billboards, on the sides of buses, on magazine covers in the check-out line, etc., etc. I'm so tired of this culture acting like modesty is a dirty word and women are only as important or worthy of affection as their sexuality decrees.

    On a different but related note, I'm bothered that women continue to put themselves in positions to be exploited, yet as a gender we generally cry out to be treated with respect. How can we expect that when we degrade ourselves? I wonder if Beyonce will want Blue Ivey to tease men with her body?

    I'm probably not making much sense, but I hope I sort of answered your question. And I hope my readers know how much I value your friendship and our honesty with one another! If only all friendships were so blessed!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Oh, I almost forgot.... I often wonder what we will do when Henry is older. We were able to watch the last season of Homeland in "real" time because DirecTV offered Showtime for free, for a limited time. In the future, would we simply say no? Would we get Netflix and lock them up? I mean, I just don't know. I don't want to be a nut-job, but I don't want to hurt my son by allowing him to watch things he's not prepared for either. (That's assuming anyone is ever prepared, but you know what I mean.)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Well, you girls are way over my head with all this, but I did watch the Super Bowl. I enjoyed the game itself because I like to see fairly evenly matched teams in the BIG game. But, for me, the best part of the Super Bowl was the Dodge commercial featuring Paul Harvey's "So God Made a Farmer." Oh, those pictures evoked such precious memories of my daddy working out in the field! Then I read about people COMPLAINING about that commercial. Atheists, agnostics, people who think farmers are obsolete...this world is in a mess! It's comforting to know there are young women like you who are willing to express your Christian values.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Mary, I can't believe that! I had no idea people felt that way about the farmer commercial. So sad. Keith and I once went to the NC State Fair and saw lots of workers wearing a tshirt I just loved. On the front it said: Naked. Hungry. Homeless. The back said: Where you'd be without NC agriculture.

    ReplyDelete